CGI or photography for e-commerce packshots at scale?
CGI pays off with many variants, unreleased products or a strict house style, while photography still wins for small ranges, soft goods and stock on the shelf.
Clear, practical guides for brands and agencies on CGI: what it costs, when to use it instead of a shoot, and how to run a project. An initiative by Not Important Studio.
CGI vs. photographyBudget & processProduct & packagingWorking with a studioTrends
CGI pays off with many variants, unreleased products or a strict house style, while photography still wins for small ranges, soft goods and stock on the shelf.
Get the heavy glass, liquid color, label finishes and condensation right by supplying real bottles and print files, and check each market's alcohol ad rules.
Usually, yes. Production CAD gives a studio the exact shape, but it lacks materials, artwork and finish, and it often needs preparation before it renders well.
Content Credentials are signed data that record how an image was made. They are voluntary, but platforms read them for AI labels, so agree on them with your studio.
Review in fixed stages, send one consolidated set of notes per round from one decision-maker, and agree in the quote what a round is and what counts as new scope.
Very accurate, if the model is built from production CAD and real stone specifications. Most errors come from lighting, scale and loose approval, not the software.
Simple CGI stills often take two to three weeks and a product film four to seven. Most delays come from missing files and slow approvals, not from rendering.
Not if the product is in CGI: swap the label artwork and render again. With photos or film, the options are retouching, partial CGI or a reshoot.
If the film runs inside an online shop or app covered by the EAA, plan for captions, a description of on-screen text, safe flashing and a way to pause.
In 3D, a new aspect ratio means moving the virtual camera and rearranging the scene, not cropping. It beats a reshoot, but each format is still real work.
Shoppers want to know when AI made an image, and labeled AI ads score lower on trust. CGI built from the real product avoids that, as long as it stays accurate.
Often the studio, unless the contract says otherwise. You usually get rights to the final images; the product model and scene files must be agreed in writing.
Published prices run from a few hundred dollars per render to six figures for a cinematic film. Liquids, shot count, revisions and usage decide where you land.
Choose CGI when the product, its materials or impossible moments carry the story. Choose photography when skin, hair and real people do. Many campaigns use both.
A good CGI brief covers product files, every visible finish, the shots and formats, where the work will run, who approves, the deadline and any embargo.
Usually not. A rendered product image is not AI output, but a label can be needed once generative AI creates or substantially changes what viewers see.
Exact geometry including glass thickness, liquid color that changes with depth, lighting built for reflections, and a real bottle to compare against.