Does a CGI film need captions under the European Accessibility Act?
It depends on where the film runs. The European Accessibility Act, which has applied since 28 June 2025, covers specific services, including e-commerce, rather than all brand video. A product film that plays inside an online shop or shopping app covered by the act should be accessible, which in practice means captions for meaningful sound, a description of information that is only shown on screen, no dangerous flashing, and a way to pause a film that starts by itself. All of that is cheapest to plan in the brief. This article is general information, not legal advice.
What is the European Accessibility Act?
An EU directive that sets accessibility requirements for a defined list of products and services.
Directive (EU) 2019/882, known as the European Accessibility Act or EAA, covers products such as computers, smartphones, e-readers and payment terminals, and services such as banking, e-books, passenger transport information, services giving access to audiovisual media, and e-commerce. It applies to products placed on the market and services provided to consumers after 28 June 2025. Each member state had to write the directive into its own national law and decides how to enforce it, and several did so late, so the national rules are not equally far along everywhere.
Two definitions matter for brands:
- E-commerce services are services provided at a distance through websites and mobile apps, at the individual request of a consumer, with a view to concluding a consumer contract (Article 3).
- Microenterprises, companies with fewer than 10 people and an annual turnover or balance sheet of no more than 2 million euros, are exempt from the requirements for services (Article 4).
Does it cover a brand’s campaign film?
Not as such. It covers the service the film appears in.
The act does not list advertising films as a category. What it regulates is the service, so the question is where your film plays. Timing matters too: Article 2(4) excludes pre-recorded video and other time-based media published before 28 June 2025 from the website and app requirements, so the obligations concern films published from that date on. Our reading, by placement:
| Where the film runs | Likely covered by the EAA? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Product page or checkout of your own online shop for EU consumers | Likely | Part of an e-commerce service |
| Your shopping app | Likely | A mobile, app-based e-commerce service |
| A retailer’s online shop | Possibly, through the retailer | The retailer is the service provider and may ask you for accessible files, although Article 2(4) excludes third-party content the operator neither funds, develops nor controls |
| A brand website where nothing can be bought | Not as e-commerce | No consumer contract is concluded there, though other rules may apply |
| Paid social and video platforms | Unclear for the ad itself | Platforms have their own obligations; the ad is not a listed service |
| Television | Mainly other rules | Broadcasting is mainly covered by the EU’s audiovisual media rules (AVMSD) rather than by this act |
Even where the act does not apply, accessible versions reach more viewers and cost little extra when they are planned from the start.
What does “accessible” mean for a product film?
In practice, the video criteria of WCAG, the web accessibility guidelines.
The directive describes requirements in general terms, such as making websites and apps perceivable, operable, understandable and robust. To make that concrete, organizations usually work from EN 301 549, the European accessibility standard for digital products and services, which refers to WCAG 2.1, according to the EU’s AccessibleEU resource center. The WCAG 2.1 criteria that touch a product film are:
| Requirement | WCAG 2.1 | Level | What it means for a CGI film |
|---|---|---|---|
| Captions | 1.2.2 | A | Captions for all prerecorded audio, including meaningful sound effects, not only speech |
| Alternative for visual information | 1.2.3 | A | Audio description or a text alternative for what is shown |
| Audio description | 1.2.5 | AA | Description of important visual information, including on-screen text, that the soundtrack does not already convey |
| Pause, stop, hide | 2.2.2 | A | Moving content that starts automatically, lasts more than five seconds and plays next to other content needs a way to pause it |
| Three flashes | 2.3.1 | A | Nothing that flashes more than three times in any one-second period, unless the flash is below the general flash and red flash thresholds |
| Text contrast | 1.4.3 | AA | On-screen text at a contrast ratio of at least 4.5:1, or 3:1 for large text |
Two of these deserve extra attention in CGI. Many product films tell their story only in images and music, with claims and product names as text on screen. W3C’s guidance on audio description explicitly counts on-screen text as visual information, so if it is not spoken, it needs describing. And fast light effects, such as sparkle on a gemstone, light sweeping across glass or a strobing transition, can cross the three-flash threshold without anyone noticing on set.
What should go in the brief?
Decide the versions at the start, because some of them are creative choices.
- Where the film will run, and whether those placements are covered. Ask your legal or e-commerce team, not the studio, to make that call.
- On-screen text with captions in mind. Leave room at the bottom of the frame, and check this against platform safe zones, which also reserve the bottom of vertical formats.
- Caption files. Ask for closed caption files per language alongside the film, plus a captioned version if a placement cannot load caption files.
- A described version. If claims or product names appear only as text, plan a voice-over or audio description version, and leave space in the sound design for it.
- A flash check. Ask the studio to review sparkle, glints and light transitions against the three-flash rule before final render.
- Contrast of supers and legal lines, checked on the final grade, not on the storyboard.
- A clean master without text, so captions, languages and later changes do not require a new render.
CGI has an advantage here: text, light effects and timing can all be adjusted in the scene and rendered again, which is harder with filmed footage. Whichever studio you work with, from a general render house to a luxury and beauty specialist such as Not Important Studio, ask for these versions as separate lines in the quote. Our brief checklist shows where they fit next to formats and channels, and our article on what a CGI beauty campaign costs explains why late changes cost the most.
What is still unclear?
Several things, so check the current position before launch:
- National differences. Member states transposed the directive in their own words, several of them late, and enforcement and penalties are set nationally.
- Scope at the edges. Whether a specific brand site, a hybrid of content and shop, or an ad placement falls under the act is not always obvious. The table above is our reading, not an official list.
- Older films. Pre-recorded video published before 28 June 2025 is excluded from the website and app requirements, so check with counsel whether a re-edit or new version published later counts as new content.
- Transition periods. Article 32 lets service providers keep using products they lawfully used to provide similar services before 28 June 2025 until 28 June 2030. That transition is about the equipment and products behind a service, not a general delay for new video.
- Standards. EN 301 549 and WCAG are updated over time, and the version used as the benchmark may change.
For a specific campaign, ask your legal team which placements are in scope, then let the studio plan the versions.
Frequently asked questions
Do burned-in captions count?
WCAG's definition of captions covers both open captions, which are part of the picture, and closed captions that viewers can switch on and off. Closed caption files make language versions easier and keep the clean picture intact.
Does the EAA affect brands based outside the EU?
It covers in-scope services provided to consumers in the EU. A brand based elsewhere that runs an online shop for EU customers should check its position with counsel.
Is a transcript enough instead of audio description?
At WCAG level A, a text alternative is one of the accepted options. Level AA, the usual target, asks for audio description of prerecorded video, so plan for both when the film carries information only on screen.
What if the film has no sound at all?
Then there is nothing to caption, but the visual information still needs an alternative. WCAG 1.2.1 asks for a text alternative or an audio track for prerecorded video-only content.
Sources
- Directive (EU) 2019/882 on the accessibility requirements for products and services (European Accessibility Act), Official Journal
- European Commission: European Accessibility Act
- AccessibleEU: Getting to know the European legislation on accessibility (guidance report)
- W3C: Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1
- W3C: Understanding Success Criterion 1.2.2, Captions (Prerecorded)
- W3C: Understanding Success Criterion 1.2.5, Audio Description (Prerecorded)