One CGI asset, every format: how do aspect ratios work in 3D?
In 3D, a new aspect ratio means moving the virtual camera and, where needed, rearranging the scene, instead of cropping a fixed frame or reshooting. That makes 16:9, 4:5, 1:1 and 9:16 versions of the same campaign far easier than in photography or film. It is not free, though: every format needs its own composition, checks and render time, so plan all of them in the brief.
Why is a new format different in 3D than in photography?
A photo or film frame is fixed, so a new format means cropping it. A 3D scene can be framed again from scratch.
Take a landscape 16:9 shot and turn it into a vertical 9:16 version by cropping at full height. You keep only about a third of the original width. The product may still fit, but the set, the light and the breathing room around it are gone, and resolution drops with them. The alternative is to shoot every format separately, which multiplies time on set.
In 3D, the whole scene still exists after the first render. Not Important Studio has written that going from 16:9 to 1:1 or 4:5 comes down to adjusting the virtual camera, and moving elements within the scene when the new composition does not work, where photography or film would mean cropping or reshooting. The product, the materials and the lighting stay exactly the same across every version.
Which formats does a campaign usually need?
Most campaigns now need four core ratios, plus whatever banners and screens the media plan adds.
| Format | Ratio | Typical placements | What the platform says |
|---|---|---|---|
| Landscape | 16:9 | YouTube, website hero, TV | YouTube calls 16:9 the standard ratio on a computer |
| Vertical | 9:16 | Reels, Stories, TikTok and other short-form feeds | Meta lists 9:16 at 1440 x 2560 pixels for Instagram Reels ads; TikTok recommends vertical 9:16 |
| Portrait | 4:5 | Facebook and Instagram feeds | Meta lists 4:5 at 1440 x 1800 pixels for Facebook Feed video ads |
| Square | 1:1 | Feeds, marketplaces, some retailer sites | TikTok supports 1:1 alongside 9:16 and 16:9 |
| Custom | Varies | Web banners, digital out-of-home, print | Set by the publisher or media owner, ask for their spec sheet |
Platform specs change, so check the current versions when you write the brief rather than relying on last year’s media plan.
What has to be redone for each format?
Camera, composition, sometimes the set, text placement and rendering. The model, materials and lighting look carry over.
Here is what usually happens per extra format:
- Camera and framing. A new camera position and lens choice for the new shape.
- Composition and set. Elements move closer or further apart. A vertical frame shows more floor and more space above the product, so the set may need to be extended.
- Text safe zones. Interface elements cover parts of the screen on social platforms. For Instagram Reels ads, Meta advises keeping at least 14% at the top, 35% at the bottom and 6% on each side free of text, logos and key design elements.
- Animation. Camera moves are retimed or redesigned. A slow sideways glide that works in 16:9 may need to become a vertical move in 9:16.
- Simulation. Liquid or particle simulations usually carry over, unless the new frame shows areas the simulation never covered.
- Rendering. Every format is rendered separately. For film, that means every frame again.
- Text and finishing. Titles, legal lines and logos are laid out again, and the grade is checked per version.
How much does an extra format cost?
A fraction of the first one, but not nothing.
The expensive parts of a CGI project happen once: building the model, developing materials, designing the look and getting it approved. An extra format reuses all of that. What you pay for is framing, layout changes, rendering and another review. Extra still formats are usually cheaper than extra film formats, because a film has to be rendered frame by frame and its camera moves may need rework.
How that translates into money depends on the studio and the shot. Our article on what a CGI beauty campaign costs explains the wider price drivers. When you compare quotes, ask each studio to price formats as separate lines, so you can see what a fourth or fifth ratio adds.
How do you plan formats in the brief?
List them all at the start and choose one master format to approve first.
- List every placement and ratio up front, including banners, retailer sites and screens. A format added late may need a set that was never built for it.
- Choose a master format, usually the one with most spend or attention, and approve the look there first.
- Ask the studio to compose with every ratio in mind, for example by keeping the product central and building the set wider and taller than the master needs.
- Approve the other formats as a batch once the master is signed off, so feedback on look and light is not repeated per version.
- Include safe zones and text versions, with and without supers, and any language versions.
- Agree file naming per format and channel, so the media team can find the right file.
Our brief checklist has a section on formats and channels you can copy.
When does reframing in 3D not save much?
When there is only one format, when real people are in the footage, or when each format needs a different idea.
If the campaign runs in a single ratio, the flexibility is nice but does not change the budget. In hybrid projects, where filmed people are combined with a CGI product, the filmed part has the same limits as any other footage. And a six-second bumper or a very wide banner is often a different edit or layout, not a reframe of the same shot. In those cases it is better to brief them as separate pieces that share the same 3D asset, as our comparison of CGI and photography for beauty campaigns also suggests for mixed productions.
Frequently asked questions
Can we add a format after the project is finished?
Yes, as long as the studio still has the scene files and you have agreed who may reuse them. Ask about archiving and file ownership before the project ends.
Is it better to render one large image and crop it?
For small ratio changes on a still, that can work. Going from 16:9 to 9:16 by cropping keeps only about a third of the width, so reframing in 3D usually gives a much better result.
Which format should we approve first?
The one that carries most of the spend or attention. For a social-first launch that is often the vertical version; for a TV or cinema spot it is the landscape master.
Does a product film need a different edit per format?
Sometimes. A camera move that works in landscape can feel slow or cramped in vertical, so the studio may adjust moves and timing per format while keeping the same story.