How do you give feedback on CGI without endless revision rounds?
Endless revision rounds are rarely caused by bad renders. They come from feedback that arrives in pieces, from people who join late, and from changes to things that were already approved. Three habits prevent most of it: review the work in fixed stages, send one consolidated set of notes per round from one person who decides, and agree in the quote what a round is and what counts as a new request.
What counts as one revision round?
One round is one consolidated set of feedback on one version, which the studio then works into the next version.
That sounds obvious, but it breaks down quickly in practice. Five emails from five colleagues about the same version are one round only if someone has merged them first. A second wave of notes on the same version, sent after the studio has started work, often counts as a new round.
The harder question is what counts as a revision at all. Mediabistro describes the difference as revisions working inside the agreed concept, while a new direction changes the concept, strategy or audience. In CGI, that line looks like this:
| Usually a revision | Usually new scope |
|---|---|
| Make the gold cap slightly warmer | Replace the cap with a new design |
| Soften the light, move a highlight | Build a different set |
| Nudge the camera, adjust framing | Add a new shot or angle |
| Slow down the liquid, change its timing | Switch from a pour to a splash |
| Adjust the color grade | Add a 9:16 version that was not in the brief |
Put this distinction in the quote. “Reasonable revisions” protects nobody.
How many rounds should a CGI quote include?
Two rounds per main stage is a common pattern, but studios count differently, so ask how yours does it.
Mediabistro reports that most agencies include two to three revision rounds in the fee and bill further rounds by the hour or per round. Charles Roberts Studios, which works mainly in architectural CGI, includes up to two rounds of amendments for each of its three review stages. ArchiCGI does not set a number of rounds: it reserves revision time equal to 60 percent of the total project hours and warns the client before that runs out.
Whichever model your studio uses, check three things in the quote:
- How many rounds are included, and for which stages
- What happens after that: the rate per extra round or per hour
- What happens to a change after a stage is approved
What should you review at each stage?
Only what that stage is meant to decide. Commenting on everything at once is how rounds multiply.
| Stage | What to judge | What to ignore for now |
|---|---|---|
| Gray model or blocking | Shape, proportions, composition, camera | Color, materials, grain, rough edges |
| Look development | Materials, light, liquid color, finish | Final framing details, small set props |
| Animation | Timing, camera movement, how the product moves | Final render quality, color grade |
| Final | Details, color grade, labels, all formats | Anything already approved |
360 Render works this way and does not revisit a stage once it is approved. ArchiCGI describes the gray stage as the point where structural changes cost least, and says major changes at the final render are more expensive. Our article on perfume bottles in CGI applies the same order to glass and liquid, with a “product truth” frame that later rounds are checked against.
How do you read rough work in progress?
As a test of the idea, not as a draft of the final image.
Early versions are meant to look unfinished. Gray products, placeholder labels, noisy renders and simple lighting are there so the idea can be judged before anyone spends days on detail. Not Important Studio has written that it sends work in progress as a recorded video walkthrough in which the team talks through the scene, so clients can watch whenever suits them and follow-up calls take less time. The studio uses rough versions to test whether an idea works before time goes into the finish, and involves the client from that early phase.
When you look at rough work, ask one question: does this answer what this stage is supposed to answer? If yes, approve it and save the polish notes for later.
How do you write feedback a studio can act on?
Specific, numbered, from one voice, and focused on the result rather than the method.
- One person consolidates. 360 Render and Charles Roberts both ask for a single person who collects everyone’s feedback and resolves conflicts before sending.
- Everyone who matters sees round one. Legal, regulatory, regional and senior reviewers who only appear at the end are the most common cause of reopened stages.
- Number every note and point to it. Mark the spot in the frame, or give the timecode in a film. ArchiCGI recommends one consolidated message per round with annotated screenshots.
- Say what is wrong and why, not how to fix it. “The cap reads too cold next to the label” works better than “add more yellow”.
- Separate must-haves from preferences. It helps the studio spend time where it counts.
- Check against the brief. If a note changes the brief, say so openly and ask what it costs.
Where should the feedback live?
In one place per round, attached to the version it is about, with the final approval recorded.
Feedback spread over email, chat and calls is hard to merge and easy to lose. Many teams use a review platform where comments sit on the exact frame and each round is kept apart. Platforms such as Kadrenta, made by the same team behind The CGI Brief, let reviewers comment on specific frames through a link without a paid account, and let the client sign off in the same place. A numbered list per round in a shared document works too, if everyone sticks to it. What matters is that there is one list, one version and one decision per round.
Why do late changes cost so much?
Because every later stage builds on the earlier ones.
Changing the shape of a bottle after the look development is approved means redoing materials, lighting and every render that shows it. Changing a splash after the simulation is approved means simulating and rendering it again. That is why a late note can cost more than an entire early round. Our article on what a CGI beauty campaign costs lists revisions and late changes among the main price drivers, and our brief checklist shows how to settle approvals before work starts.
Frequently asked questions
Can we ask for unlimited revisions?
You can ask, but few studios will agree, and those that do usually price in a large margin. A fixed number of rounds per stage with a clear rate for extra rounds is easier to plan on both sides.
Who should be the decision-maker?
Someone senior enough to settle disagreements inside your company, and available on the review dates. It does not have to be the most senior person, as long as that person's views are collected before each round.
What if a senior executive only sees the work at the end?
Then their notes can reopen approved stages, which is the most expensive kind of change. Show senior stakeholders the work at the first review, even briefly, so their direction is in from the start.
Do we pay for rounds we do not use?
It depends on the studio. Included rounds are often part of a fixed fee, so unused ones are not refunded, but some studios will move them to a later stage if you ask early. Agree on this in the quote.